
Recently in the United States, a Catholic bishop asked a priest under his authority (an exorcist) to step back from his public engagements for a year.
The reasons for this are – as my students say in their essays – many and varied. But I’m not wading into these, because the comments on The Catholic Weekly‘s Facebook page are already too frazzled.
Instead, I’m going to lean on a friend who made a wise observation that gave me this week’s column topic.
He said, “Yesterday I saw a comment which concluded with ‘It is our responsibility to spread the news about him, to introduce others to him.’ They weren’t referring to Jesus; they were referring to Fr [exorcist].”
And there’s the problem. My criticisms of Catholic online celebrity culture have been well aired in the past. That’s because I’ve always been worried about the corrosive effects of cheap fame, likes, the 24-hour media cycle, and easy money on otherwise good people.
These stories so often don’t end well for anyone involved, both celebrity Catholics and superfans alike. But my friend’s comment opened a whole new dimension of awfulness for me to dislike about Catholic celebrity culture.
That’s the cult of Catholic personality that can overpower our primary relationship – the one that really matters – with God.
We will spread the word about our favourite celebrity Catholic’s doings, but we won’t spread the word about the saviour who they are supposed to represent.
The good news is that this problem is as old as the church. St Paul had to deal with it when he tackled the Corinthians, with his followers, Peter’s followers, and Apollos’ followers at each other’s throats (1 Cor 1:12).
So we already have the solution. Paul told us to see our growth in faith as a group assignment: Paul plants the seed, Apollos waters it, but God makes it grow.
There have also been Catholic influencers since the foundation of the church. Some of them we call “saints”.
Your good influences today may include people you’ve seen online through listening to or watching their talks and homilies. But do you really know these people?
Since the beginning of last century, mass communications media has been doing strange things to how we relate to each other.

It’s made it possible for increasingly lonely people to form what we call “parasocial” relationships. You might know this as the old-fashioned celebrity and/or fictional character crush. You adore them, but they don’t know you exist.
You over-invest in their real or fictional life at the expense of your real-life relationships. There’s an illusion of intimacy, but no reality behind it.
I think some Catholics are at risk of forming parasocial relationships with celebrity online Catholics, at the expense of forming real relationships with people a lot closer to them.
That includes Jesus Christ himself, the person who should always be closest to you. It should include your local parish community, who are probably not always very glamorous or interesting.
It should include your family members, who are so often irritating and humbling. It should include your workmates or colleagues, no matter how odd you find them. This is your part of the vineyard. How well are you tending it?
This week the Vatican released a document on where we’re falling short in passing on our faith, and how we can improve.
It said straight out (s.81) that “for the transmission of the faith to be truly effective, it must take the form of an engaging interpersonal relationship.”
The Gospel is spread through real relationships with real people, based on listening, answering questions, and building trust.
You don’t need to be charming or delightful all the time. You just need to be in love with God, and willing to share that love with another person if they’re interested.
And if you’re in love with God, you will absolutely want to share him with everyone. But you will have different conversations with different people.
You will have to listen first to gauge where that person is in their curiosity or sense of being called towards the truth. Not everyone’s at the same place or has the same background knowledge as you.
But if all your time and energy is spend gorging on Catholic in-house scandals online, that content is going to dominate how you speak about the church and about God to other people.
You run the risk of not only making yourself miserable, but of losing opportunities to win souls for Christ. Have a think about this and see if you need to make some changes.







