Captain’s pick for the world’s toughest job

Most read

Pope Leo XIV waves to the crowd from the central balcony of St. Peter’s Basilica at the Vatican as he leads, for the first time, the midday recitation of the “Regina Coeli” prayer May 11, 2025. (CNS photo/Vatican Media)

I never ever thought that a gringo would be elected pope. Never ever. There you go. As Pope Francis used to say, our God is a God of surprises. One punter with Polymarket walked away with US$65,000 after placing a bet at 66 to 1 on this unknown guy called Cardinal Prevost. If Catholics wanted empirical proof of the hand of God in electing the Bishop of Rome, they have it now.  

Fun fact: in 1899 Leo XIII—an incredible overachiever who deserves to be canonised— condemned the heresy of “Americanism”. This meant, more or less, relying on activism rather than prayer to get to heaven. And now his successor is a prayerful American missionary. The God of surprises. 

The election of a pope, like funerals of the British royal family, the FIFA World Cup, weddings of the British royal family, and the opening ceremony of the Olympics, is a spectacle which draws hundreds of millions of viewers worldwide. But there’s a difference. The others are forgotten in a week. A pope can change the world.  

- Advertisement -

Not quickly. Not violently. But slowly and surely. Stalin reportedly sneered when Churchill referred to Pius XII, “How many divisions does the pope have?” The answer then and now is: none. But Stalin is dead and buried. So is the USSR. At least the pope still has a Swiss Guard and a country. 

Archbishop Michael Wallace Banach, apostolic nuncio to Hungary, then-Archbishop Robert Francis Prevost, prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops, and then-Archbishop Claudio Gugerotti, prefect of the Dicastery for Eastern Churches, are pictured at Protection of the Mother of God Greek Catholic Church in Budapest April 29, 2023. Pope Francis made an apostolic visit to Hungary April 28-30. (OSV News photo/Attila Lambert, courtesy of Magyar Kurir)

Leo XIV’s influence will reach far beyond the Catholic Church to change hearts and form intellects. In the long run, he can make a huge difference. Let me list seven key areas.

  1. The 21st century is the biotech century. Scientists are racing to build technologies to manipulate the human genome with CRISPR and other gene-editing technologies. DIY eugenics will become common. Who will be the most eloquent defender of human dignity against these atrocities? The Catholic Church.
  2. “AI is likely to be either the best or worst thing to happen to humanity,” says Elon Musk. AI could create incredible opportunities for business and technology. It could also destroy us. To navigate the ethical challenges ahead, society needs to have a clear understanding of what human beings are, of what natural intelligence is. And the church is, as St Paul VI told the United Nations in 1965, “an expert in humanity.” Leo XIV has already said that AI is one of the items on his agenda.
  3. Everyone agrees that global population is falling off a cliff. Birth rates are sinking far below replacement level in North and South America, Australia, Europe, Asia, the Middle East –everywhere except sub-Saharan With Africa supplying the world’s workers, African migration will transform the world. And where is the Catholic Church growing fastest and where are the faithful most fervent? Africa. The church’s global influence will be massive.

    Pope Leo XIV greets photographers as he welcomes members of the media who covered his election, during a meeting in the Paul VI Audience Hall at the Vatican May 12, 2025. (CNS photo/Lola Gomez)
  4. No one does youth better than the Catholic Church. Does the church have difficulties in attracting committed youth? Yes, but every other institution and political movement is failing to crack the youth market. The church does it best. It is “a beacon that illumines the dark nights of this world,” as Leo XIV said in a homily to the cardinals who elected Look at the crowds at World Youth Days, at the trips of John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Francis. I predict this new pope will shatter those records. 
  5. The Western world is being ripped apart by wokeness. Who is the most convincing opponent of moral relativism? Who presents rigorous arguments for perennial moral truths, for Truth with a capital T? Who defends the natural law and human rationality? By and large, only the Catholic Church.
  6. “Evil will not prevail,” said Leo in his first words as pope. Hopefully the Holy See can help to broker peace in Ukraine and Gaza and other terror-torn parts of the world. But at least it will remind world leaders that the ultimate geopolitical goal must be “a civilisation of love,” not domination. No other leader commands respect as the pope does. He will be the conscience of global politics.
  7. Above all, hope. Power, unfettered sex, success, wealth, and consumerism are illusions. “A lack of faith is often tragically accompanied by the loss of meaning in life, the neglect of mercy, appalling violations of human dignity, the crisis of the family and so many other wounds that afflict our society,” said Pope Leo XIV in his homily. Christianity, faith in the saving message of Jesus Christ, offers firm hope for a better world, here and hereafter. And Robert Francis Prevost now owns the world’s biggest Christian megaphone.  
Pope Leo XIV speaks to representatives of the media who covered his election in the Paul VI Audience Hall at the Vatican May 12, 2025. (CNS photo/Lola Gomez)

The God of surprises has surprised us again. Who could have predicted that the successor of Francis would be familiar with both middle-class North America and impoverished South America? Would be both a missionary and a Vatican bureaucrat? Would be both a man of prayer and a competent administrator? 

In short, Cardinal Prevost is the captain’s pick for the world’s toughest job. 

- Advertisement -

- Advertisement -